Mama Mia`s Pizzeria in Erie

surprised this place is still opened after everything that has happened 16 years ago! awesome pizza and definitely recommend!

SAVE YOUR TIME AND MONEY.

I know I'm late to party, but I had their pizza for the first time tonight and this is going to be my go-to from now on. Keep up the good work 👍

My favorite pizza place since I was 12 years old

After the in laws returned from vacation no one wanted to cook. We ordered two large ham & cheese calazones (best in town!), a large cheese & pep and a large antipasto. The 'zones, just ham & cheese, were great, super fresh pizza, and the salad wasn't the usual chunk lunch meat with old tomatoes, they took the time to roll and slice the meats deli style. Everything was great!

Italian food at this location - very tasty. the food was amazing. i had a cousin come into town and asked me to take him back here. it has a cool feel to it. food is like a restaurant in louisville i liked.

Our favorite pizza and a Friday family tradition. Glad you are back!

Placed an order for pickup - good service and reasonable prices, but food was average at best

Very good pizza.

They have great pizza.

I love Mama Mias! My work orders from there every couple of months. They have the best anti-pasta salad and the staff is so friendly. Will definitely order from there again!. 5 Stars for awesome staff!

Good quality toppings. Friendly service and quick delivery. The only draw back was the lack of seasonings for their pizza sauce. If they had some more seasoning to "spice it up" a little, the pizza would have been perfect.

we ordered 2 calzones and a pizza tonight and the food was AMAZING! Everyone was super friendly-it was fast and so good. Will definitely be our new go to pizza place!

Stopped here before going back to Buffalo,NY on way from shopping and wanted to have something that was not a chain restaurant. Food was delicious and tasted fresh out of Italian kitchen. Tammy one of the owners, I believe made us feel like we were long time customers, and was only our first visit. Stromboli was made fresh to order...and loved having the choice of three different sizes of anti pasta. Will defintly stop again to either try or bring home pizza or calzone.

The first time I went it was outstanding the second time it was just ok

i don't get the Bender family complaints. I am a 30+ year vegetarian and I can tell you that almost all restaurants will accommodate you, but YES, THE IS USUALLY A CHARGE IF YOU ARE ASKING TO CANCEL HALF THE ITEMS AND ADD THREE EXTRA ITEMS. The owner is always willing to make me anything I want, and the results are delicious. I am always informed of the price beforehand, no surprises. And everyone there treats me as well as if they have known me my whole life!

Excellent pizza!!!! Great quality at a great price!

Italian sub (combo) very good. We may come back for pizza. Workers very nice.

Each time we have a pizza party at our office we always order from Mama Mia's. Sometimes our orders are pretty large and they always have it delivered on time, hot, and fresh. Their prices are great and the staff is even better. Thank you for making our lunches awesome!

Always great food and great service!

Great Pizza! You won't be disappointed! Everyone is friendly and helpful. Give 'em a try...

Really good pizza and calzone. Happily gave us a side of ranch and marinara. Will definitely be getting a calzone from here again!

Good pizza, thin and yummy. Kids liked it. Parking wasn't great.

Very yummy! Super nice folks!

Great salads and pizzas. Love their pizza balls too. Friendly people that work there. 💓

Ordered 4 pizzas+2 lg antipastos, done on time! hot n fresh! The newer owners(family) are awesome, always attentive n friendly+ place cleaner than its ever been! They were smart in not changing the crust/sauce recipe, so now its the always reliable neighborhood pizza joint of 18+yrs w attentive owners (who work there!) that VALUE your business and put out a top quality meal. Only light complaint I would have is the "x-tra" cheese could have been a titch heavier! Hope they are here to stay+keep up the obvious great effort!

I've passed this place hundreds of times and I've spent the last 2 years living just down the road from them. Finally decided to give them a try and was thrilled to discover one of the best slices in Erie. Their pizza reminds me of the way I remember pizza tasting as a kid. Melty cheese, thin crust, and just the right about of sauce. A 5/5 pizza for the price. Highly recommend.

Best pizza in the city! Nice people who run the place.

Hands down my favorite local pizza place in Erie.

My family just devoured a chicken bacon ranch and margherita pizza! First time customers, but not last time customers! Definitely will be a pizza to go to place!

Love their pizza balls, they let me add mushroom which is the best thing to me, they have a nice crispy outside and soft inside cooked perfectly. I like their salads lettuce is fresh and all ingredients are tasty. My husband gets the BLT, The subs are nicely toasted with good ingredients, only thing I'd suggest is strips of bacon instead of crushed bacon but other then that it's all very good food. The employees are very friendly and always check how the food is/was make sure that we get what we need and they always seem to be working hard.

Staff was so friendly and the pizza was really good. I will definitely be back.

I ordered food and they said to call when I got there. I called and they saw my car. I then waited 30 minutes and had to call them back. The girl laughed at me and said it was done and had been sitting there. The manager then brought it out and when I told him I didn’t want it because it was cold he threw it in my car window and walked away. I called today, the manager then told me to order from somewhere else. They need to hire a new manager and new staff apparently. The owners apparently don’t care how they treat customers!

Clean environment, friendly staff, good price, good food, great portions.

Decent pizza joint. Sit down restaurant could use a decor update. Prices are reasonable. Food was average, pizza wasn't the greatest but not horrible. Calzones were pretty tasty. Staff was friendly. Limited parking.

Very good food and nice people

First time in the new location. Take out only right now. Got a couple of subs. Food is good but I wouldn't call it great.

Pizza and breadsticks great. Quick service, delivered to our hotel room door. Provided plates and napkins too.

We are here visiting from canada and decided to give this a try. We cant say enough about how absolutely delicious this pizza was! We loved it, best pizza I've had in a really long time. Delivery was MUCH quicker than anticipated and everyone was so kind :)Highly recommend!

Was not pleased at all. When we called to tell them they made the order wrong, they hung up on us twice. When we did get ahold of someone, they blamed us for the order being wrong. Needless to say we will never order from them again. Rude management and rude employees.

Hot,fresh, delicious AND visually appealing! Chicken ranch pizza and meatball zombie sub hot the spot! The sub wasn't trashed and the pizza was very tasty! I used to eat here often,as a child and it's very nice to see they are still banging out great pizza so many years later . Two thumbs way up 👍👍

Delicious pizza very friendly staff.will definitely will return for another meal

I just ordered here for the first time, and it was super delicious. I'm very picky and this pizza and wings definitely hit the spot for me. Thank you too whoever made our order. Also the lady who took my order and the lady who delivered it, were both very polite. Also my order came way before I expected it to. So overall very good!! I highly recommend!!

Best pizza and Stromboli Erie has! Once you eat here you'll never go back to chain stores! I can't say enough about how good there pizza is. New goto!

Tiniest sub I've ever had, on old bread. Sorry, you lost a lifelong customer.

First time very good food

First time customers, and we order a Italian sub, and a family Italian, hands down fanominal subs, wife order a side of zucchini that was a little under cooked this the reason a 4 star! Great service and very respectful, we will definitely be back! Sincerely Robert Chance and Dawn Brown!

Good food, good prices

Best pizza in Erie! I just wish they had a little later hours... as I work 3rd shift! 😢

Good, clean, friendly place.